The following unabridged reviews are made available under license from their respective rights holders and publishers. Reviews may be used for educational purposes consistent with the fair use doctrine in your jurisdiction, and may not be reproduced or repurposed without permission from the rights holders.

Note: This section may include reviews for related titles (e.g., same author, series, or related edition).

From Cooperative Children's Book Center (CCBC)

Viola “Vi” Reyes (Filipina American) is smart, forthright, and uncompromising. Jack “Duke” Orsino (biracial Black/white) is talented, charming, and easygoing. The general consensus among their high school classmates is that Vi should be nicer, and Jack is Mr. Nice Guy. Vi and Duke serve on student council, where he shows no interest in leadership and she carries the load. Star athlete Duke, couch-bound after an injury, discovers the world of ConQuest, an MMORPG game where, it turns out, Vi, is a high-achieving player who goes by Cesario. After Duke realizes Cesario goes to his school, Vi lies and says she’s her twin brother, Bash. Online, Vi—as Bash—joins forces with Duke on a quest. In the real world, Duke, longing to understand why his girlfriend Olivia broke up with him, cuts a deal with Vi: He’ll take on a vexing student council task (“You mean you’ll do your job?”) if she’ll try to find out why. Vi becomes friends with Olivia even as she and Duke grow close. This delightful reimagining of Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night isn’t all fun and games. Among the social commentary and insights are Vi’s constant battles with sexism; Jack’s realization that he’s crafted his nice guy persona to ease his life as a Black athlete at their predominantly white high school; and the homophobia Olivia reveals in her extended family. Still, there’s plenty of humor, love, and romance along with reckoning as truths are revealed.

CCBC Choices 2025 © Cooperative Children's Book Center, Univ. of Wisconsin – Madison, 2025. Used with permission.

From School Library Journal

June 1, 2024

Gr 9 Up-Being student VP to Jack "Duke" Orsino's student body president is frustrating. Add in a recent fallout with her tabletop group, and Vi Reyes's only safe haven is her MMORPG Twelfth Knight, where she plays as a male character. However, Vi's sacred gaming space is changed when a football injury benches Jack for the season. He is introduced to Twelfth Knight and unknowingly begins late nights gaming with Vi. There's just one problem; Vi's pretending to be her brother Bash online. While the pair build a virtual friendship, Vi grapples with telling Jack the truth, especially when their real-world interactions begin to spark feelings. Follmuth's sophomore YA novel is as lively as it is charming. The modernization of Shakespeare's work perfectly showcases teens grappling with anger over life circumstances. Vi is no stranger to inequality, and her gruff, guarded demeanor will resonate with many readers. Jack's search for positivity, coinciding with the potential loss of his future, hits the reality that life is more than just a game; it's about the people who stand with you. As Vi and Jack's relationship develops, both learn to appreciate the other while ultimately finding that having conviction, sensitivity, and steadfastness isn't bad if one cultivates and communicates with the people they love. Jack is Black, and Vi is contextually cued as Latinx. VERDICT A coming-of-age Shakespearean revamp where building personal connections, while unapologetically being yourself, is at the forefront of this romantic comedy.-Emily Walker

Copyright 2024 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

From Booklist

May 1, 2024
Grades 8-12 Jack "Duke" Orsino is the handsome, charming, and popular star running back of the Messaline High football team. Viola (Vi) Reyes is an angry, snarky gamer girl with a million nerd T-shirts and a habit of pushing people away. But when Jack tears his ACL and his girlfriend, Olivia, mysteriously breaks up with him, he recruits Vi to uncover the real reason behind her excuses. Meanwhile, as Jack's knee heals, he dives into the online world of Twelfth Knight, a fantasy MMORPG where he meets and befriends Cesario, a seasoned player who guides Jack through the game. The only problem? Cesario is secretly Vi, who uses male alter egos to avoid online hate. As the two begin to see past the other's walls and masks, they each must decide what to share and what to hide. Chock-full of Shakespeare references and gamer culture, with nods to nerd franchises like Game of Thrones and D&D, this adorkable Twelfth Night retelling from the author of My Mechanical Romance (2022) is the stuff that rom-coms are made of.

COPYRIGHT(2024) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From Kirkus

April 15, 2024
Viola Reyes is a gamer, a fangirl, and a feminist. Vi plays tabletop games and massively multiplayer online role-playing games, and she obsessively watches the medieval fantasy TV show War of Thorns. She loves to spend time at Renaissance faires and fan conventions, where she can be herself. Unfortunately, male-dominated fandoms aren't always welcoming to female-identifying and presenting people. More often than not, Vi is forced to defend herself and her right to exist in fandom circles. She plays as Cesario, a boy, in Twelfth Knight, her current MMORPG, so she can actually enjoy the game rather than battle constant harassment. Meanwhile, Jack "Duke" Orsino is student body president (Vi is the vice president) and high school football royalty. When he seriously injures his knee and is benched for the season, he starts playing Twelfth Knight, too--and DukeOrsino12 encounters Cesario. When the two begin chatting and teaming up within the game, Vi panics and pretends to be her twin brother, Sebastian. This engaging modern retelling of Shakespeare's Twelfth Night has a genderbending plot that's a perfect fit for contemporary readers. While some of the allusions will be a bit too on the nose for anyone familiar with the source material (and may make suspending disbelief difficult for some), the slow-burn enemies-to-lovers storyline (and the absence of Twelfth Night's sinister subplot) more than carry this successful adaptation. Duke is Black, and Vi is cued Latine. A delightful nerd romance. (dramatis personae) (Romance. 14-18)

COPYRIGHT(2024) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From AudioFile Magazine

In this updated retelling of Shakespeare's TWELFTH NIGHT, the classic tale of false identities and gender-swapping is enhanced by the talented narrations of Alexandra Palting and Kevin R. Free. Their youthful and energetic performances bring to life injured football player Jack Orsino and geeky tabletop gamer Viola Reyes, who meet up in an MMORPG (massively multiplayer online role-playing game) called Twelfth Knight and develop a strong emotional connection. Free and Palting's nuanced voices help listeners enjoy the twists and turns of this enjoyable young adult romance. Both narrators display finesse in navigating their characters' development. C.F. © AudioFile 2024, Portland, Maine