The following unabridged reviews are made available under license from their respective rights holders and publishers. Reviews may be used for educational purposes consistent with the fair use doctrine in your jurisdiction, and may not be reproduced or repurposed without permission from the rights holders.

Note: This section may include reviews for related titles (e.g., same author, series, or related edition).

From Cooperative Children's Book Center (CCBC)

Max Plink’s teeth seem to be the cause of most of her problems. Her severe overbite requires expensive, painful orthodontia—including her new headgear, or “jawbreaker”—and the frightening potential of double jaw surgery down the road. The expense is straining her family’s already stretched-thin finances; her parents fight over money, and her dad drinks too much. Max’s younger sister, Alexis, joins the bullies at school in relentlessly tormenting Max, calling her Bucky Beaver and worse. To top it all off, a local journalism competition for junior high students, which Max has long hoped to win, decides to accept only video entries, not essays, and Max is loath to appear onscreen. Amid the chaos she finds comfort in a blog written by a young man who chronicled his own experience with double jaw surgery—and the bullying that preceded it—and a lightbulb goes on. For her application, Max will report on bullying in schools. And, if she’s brave enough to wear it in the video, surely her headgear will make an impact. While Max’s jawbreaker is the titular topic, it turns out it’s not the root of her problems. Unflinching in its depiction of a host of challenges that can stem from intergenerational trauma, toxic family dynamics, and poverty (including lack of access to technology needed for schoolwork), this novel ends on a high note as Max and her family (white) commit to communicating, seeking help, and being kinder to one another. (Ages 8-12)

CCBC Choices 2024 © Cooperative Children's Book Center, Univ. of Wisconsin - Madison, 2024. Used with permission.

From Booklist

November 1, 2023
Grades 5-8 For a kid like Max Plink--five feet eight with frizzy hair, braces, and an extreme overbite--seventh grade is no picnic. Bullies delight in calling her Bucky Beaver, Maxi-Pad, and Train-Wreck Face, but the names sting a lot more when her younger sister starts joining in. A trip to the orthodontist proves the icing on the worst cake ever when Max learns that her "maxillofacial deformity" is so severe that it may require surgery if she doesn't start wearing a type of headgear known as a jawbreaker. Thankfully, Max doesn't have to use it at school, but it's a literal pain to wear, and the prospect of serious surgery is frightening to contemplate. Wyman's debut is a wonderfully messy slice of life that gives space to kids dealing with bullying, sibling conflict, economic insecurity, and parents coping with divorce and alcoholism. Yet, there is hope to be found. All the characters are realistically flawed, and Max experiences significant growth as she weathers middle school's cruelties and takes positive action through a journalism project. An inspiring underdog tale.

COPYRIGHT(2023) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From School Library Journal

September 1, 2023

Gr 5-7-In a novel inspired by the author's own childhood, seventh grader Max Plink has a Class II malocclusion, also known as severe overbite, which typical braces are not able to correct. Her orthodontist, Dr. Watson, has been talking about potential surgery that would wire her mouth shut for weeks. Max is currently wearing painful headgear that she calls the "jawbreaker" to try to avoid the surgery. Her parents are struggling financially and the additional cost of dentistry, plus her dad's substance abuse problem, has put a strain on the family. Max's younger sister Alexis is hanging out at school with kids who bully Max about her appearance and the two fight constantly at home. The bright spot in Max's days is spending time with her friend Shrynn, although she has been distant recently while dealing with her own family issues. The two work for the school newspaper and participate in a competition to work with journalist Jordan Slade. Readers will relate to Max's experiences dealing with bullies, trying to complete assignments without the technological resources of her peers, navigating changing family dynamics, and enduring typical preteen angst. VERDICT This heartfelt story about a common middle school experience of having braces will appeal to fans of Raina Telgemeier's Smile.-Sarah Polace

Copyright 2023 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

From Kirkus

Starred review from September 1, 2023
Bullying, family strife, and a severe overbite set the stage for this gut-wrenching but overall optimistic tale set in Brooklyn. Twelve-year-old Maximillia Plink's life is already difficult enough without the painful headgear for her braces that her orthodontist makes her wear to correct a complicated overbite. But she's also contending with the looming possibility of double jaw surgery, her parents' increasingly frequent arguing, and her family's financial struggles. The worst things, however, are the relentless abuse by bullies (chief among them her own younger sister), paired with what feels like a lack of support and cluelessness from the adults around her. When a journalism competition is announced at school, Max must choose whether to follow her dreams or shy away from submitting the required video essay for fear of being targeted for even more bullying. Inspired by her own life experiences, in her debut, Wyman explores typical junior high stresses such as navigating friendships while deftly exploring serious topics like toxic family dynamics, substance abuse, and the psychological toll of bullying. Interwoven with the weight of heavy topics is a message of hope, perseverance, and self-acceptance presented in a humorous and relatable way. It's this accessible, balanced approach to painful and emotionally charged situations that makes this book so wildly successful. Max and her family are white; there is racial diversity among the supporting characters. A hugely relatable must-read: witty, intensely emotional, and full of heart. (author's note) (Fiction. 8-12)

COPYRIGHT(2023) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

From Publisher's Weekly

Starred review from August 21, 2023
Smile meets Wonder in Wyman's affirming debut, a South Brooklynâ€"set novel that probes the intersection between bullying and orthodontia through the eyes of Maximillia "Max" Audrina Plink, a 12-year-old of Italian descent. Nicknamed "Bucky Beaver" and otherwise taunted by cruel classmates, aspiring journalist Max loathes her splayed teeth, severe overbite, and jaws that "fit together like mismatched puzzle pieces." Her Class II malocclusion's painful, costly treatmentâ€"braces, headgear (which Max dubs "the jawbreaker"), and possible surgeryâ€"strains the family's already lean finances and triggers harassment from Max's sister. As Max navigates friendships, feuding parents, a father who increasingly smells of alcohol, and a journalism competition that requires a video essay, she slowly gains the courage to speak up for herselfâ€"and against academic inequities, bullying, and intergenerational trauma. Portraying complex social concepts with nuance, Max's candid, accessible first-person narration propels her growing pains and journey toward empowerment, leading to a hopeful conclusion emphasizing the idea that "no one should have to look perfect just to be treated well." An author's note discusses the story's personal roots. Secondary characters suggest the presence of racial diversity. Ages 8â€"12. Agent: Erin Murphy, Erin Murphy Literary.